When considering purchasing a second home, one of the most important factors to understand is the interest rate you'll be paying on your mortgage. Interest rates for second homes, which are properties you intend to occupy in addition to your primary residence for part of the year or for investment purposes, are typically higher than those for primary residences, as lenders view them as riskier investments.

In this article, we'll dive into the current state of interest rates for second homes, the factors that influence these rates, and what you need to know before buying a second property.

Please note, at the time of writing, the average interest rate for a home mortgage is hovering around 7%. However, this rate is subject to change and will also be determined based on a number of factors including your credit score, the loan-to-value ratio, and the location of the property.

Home mortgage rate trends - March 2024
Source: Nerdwallet

What Counts as a Second Home?

A second home, commonly known as a vacation home, is a property you own apart from your primary residence. It's a dwelling where you spend part of the year, distinguishing it from your main living quarters. The loan obtained to finance this purchase is termed a second home mortgage.

Second Homes Percentage Housing

Data from the National Association of Home Builders revealed there were 7.15 million second homes in the U.S. in 2020, making up 5.11% of the total housing stock. Since then, particularly influenced by the pandemic, there has been a significant rise in vacation home purchases in the latter half of 2020 and into early 2021, reflecting a shift in lifestyle and work dynamics.

To be considered a second home by a mortgage lender, a property needs to adhere to specific qualifications:

  1. It must be a single-family home.
  2. It should be habitable throughout the year, not merely for seasonal occupancy.
  3. You're expected to reside there for a certain period annually.
  4. The ownership must grant you exclusive control of the property, which excludes timeshares or properties under the management of property management companies.
  5. The property cannot be leased out full-time, nor can you depend on rental income to service the mortgage.

These criteria ensure that the property genuinely serves as a personal retreat rather than a rental investment, distinguishing second homes in the financial landscape.

Investment Home vs. Second Home

Deciding whether to buy a house or invest is a significant decision.

An investment property allows you to explore the realm of real estate investment, focusing on long-term financial gains through rental income. Unlike a second home, an investment property is not a place where you would typically spend vacations or live part-time; it's purely for income generation or capital appreciation.

If your objective with a property is to earn rental income, lenders will categorize it as an investment property, affecting the mortgage terms. Investment properties often necessitate a larger down payment than second homes due to the perceived higher risk by lenders.

Thus, if you're deliberating between purchasing a personal retreat or making an investment, an investment property presents a path to encompass both objectives, marrying the idea of real estate ownership with investment.

Primary Residence

Your primary residence is more than just an address; it's where your life unfolds for the majority of the year. It stands in contrast to investment properties, as it serves as your personal living space rather than a source of rental income. The emotional value of a primary residence often surpasses its investment potential.

However, if you're contemplating transitioning your primary home into an investment property to tap into potential rental income, it's essential to navigate this shift carefully. This includes obtaining consent from your mortgage lender to avoid violating the terms of your loan and consulting with a tax advisor to understand the ramifications, such as potential changes in your tax liabilities and benefits. This preparation ensures you're well-informed about the financial and legal aspects of such a transformation, safeguarding your interests and optimizing your property's value.

Factors That Influence Interest Rates for Second Homes

Several key factors can impact the interest rate you'll pay on a second home mortgage:

  1. Market Trends: Current mortgage rates are influenced by market trends. The good news is that experts predict mortgage rates may decrease in 2024 as inflation cools.
  2. Risk to the Lender: Mortgage lenders view second home mortgages as riskier investments compared to primary residence mortgages. This is because borrowers are more likely to prioritize payments on their primary home if they face financial challenges. As a result, interest rates for second homes are often slightly higher.
  3. Credit Score: Borrowers with higher credit scores generally qualify for more favorable interest rates on second home mortgages. Most lenders require a credit score of at least 640, but the exact threshold can vary by lender.
  4. Location: Mortgage rates can vary significantly by state. If your second home is located in an area with higher property values than your primary residence, you may face higher interest rates.
  5. Loan-to-Value (LTV) Ratio: The loan-to-value ratio compares the amount you're borrowing to the appraised value of the property. A lower LTV ratio, which you can achieve by making a larger down payment, can help you secure better interest rates by reducing the lender's risk.
  6. Loan Amount and Type: The size of your loan and the type of mortgage you choose can also impact your interest rate. Larger loans may come with higher rates, and different loan structures (such as fixed-rate vs. adjustable-rate mortgages) will have different rate offerings.
  7. Debt-to-Income (DTI) Ratio: Your debt-to-income ratio is the percentage of your monthly income that goes toward debt payments, including your mortgage. For a second home, most lenders prefer a DTI ratio of 36% or less, but some may allow up to 43%.
  8. Cash Reserves: Having significant cash reserves available after closing can help you secure more favorable mortgage terms. Lenders view borrowers with ample cash reserves as less risky.

Pros and Cons of Second Home Mortgages

Venturing into the acquisition of a second home necessitates a thorough analysis of its merits and drawbacks, ensuring that your investment decision is well-informed and aligned with your financial goals and lifestyle.

Advantages

  • Tax Deductions: A compelling incentive for many second home buyers is the ability to deduct mortgage interest and property taxes on a second home, similar to the tax benefits enjoyed with a primary residence. As of the latest guidelines, you can deduct up to $750,000 ($375,000 if married filing separately) in mortgage interest across both properties. Furthermore, property tax deductions are collectively capped at $10,000. These tax deductions can significantly reduce the overall cost of owning a second home, making it a more attractive investment.
  • Using Equity from Your Primary Residence: A strategic advantage in financing a second home is the option to tap into the equity of your primary residence. This can be achieved through a cash-out refinance or securing a home equity line of credit (HELOC), providing a substantial source of funding for the down payment on your second property. This approach can facilitate the purchase without depleting your liquid assets, leveraging your existing property investment to expand your real estate portfolio.

Disadvantages

  • Higher Costs: One of the key considerations when purchasing a second home is the higher interest rates typically associated with second home mortgages. These elevated rates reflect the lender's increased risk perception, leading to higher monthly mortgage payments compared to those of a primary residence. This cost disparity emphasizes the need for careful financial planning and budgeting to manage the additional financial burden.
  • Stricter Qualification Requirements: Securing a mortgage for a second home often involves navigating more rigorous qualification criteria. Lenders impose stricter standards for credit scores and debt-to-income ratios, reflecting their cautious stance on the heightened risk of lending for second homes. This can make qualifying for a second home mortgage more challenging, requiring prospective buyers to have a strong financial profile. Additionally, prospective buyers should be prepared for a more thorough scrutiny of their financial situation, including proving that they can afford the mortgage payments on both their primary and secondary residences, further emphasizing the need for financial stability and readiness.

Types of Second Home Mortgages

When financing a second home, you have a variety of mortgage options at your disposal, each with its unique features and benefits:

  1. Fixed-Rate Mortgages: Opting for a fixed-rate mortgage means your interest rate stays constant over the entire loan term. This stability offers peace of mind and eases financial planning by ensuring your monthly payments don't change, helping you manage your budget with greater certainty.
  2. Adjustable-Rate Mortgages (ARMs): ARMs start with lower interest rates than fixed-rate mortgages, making them attractive for short-term savings. However, the interest rate adjusts after a predetermined period based on market conditions, potentially leading to higher future monthly payments. This variability requires a level of financial flexibility and risk acceptance.
  3. Interest-Only Loans: These loans allow you to pay just the interest on the mortgage for a specified initial period, reducing your monthly outlay in the early years. However, once this period ends and you begin repaying the principal, your monthly costs will increase. This option can be appealing if you anticipate higher income in the future or plan to sell the home before larger payments begin.
  4. Balloon Mortgages: Featuring initially lower monthly payments, balloon mortgages culminate in a significant lump-sum payment at the loan's end. This option can be advantageous for those expecting to have ample funds in the future to cover the balloon payment, but it requires careful financial planning and risk management.

Selecting the right mortgage type for your second home is a crucial decision that hinges on your personal financial situation, risk tolerance, and long-term objectives. Whether seeking predictability, lower initial payments, or planning for a future sale, carefully weigh each option's pros and cons to align with your financial strategy and goals.

Where to Find Current Second Home Mortgage Rates

Identifying competitive interest rates is pivotal in reducing the overall cost of your second home mortgage. Diligent comparison of mortgage rates can unveil more advantageous loan conditions.

Below are several platforms offering up-to-date comparisons of second home mortgage rates, facilitating an easier decision-making process:

For additional information, conducting a search with keywords such as "interest rates for second homes" or "second home mortgage rates" on your favorite search engine can lead to a broader array of lenders and financial institutions. This approach ensures you have a well-rounded view of the options available, empowering you to secure the best possible terms for your mortgage.

How to Buy a Second Home

Purchasing a second home involves a series of steps that may slightly differ based on your chosen location, lender, and the type of loan. Here's a streamlined overview of the process:

  1. Assess Affordability: Start by evaluating your finances to ensure you can handle the extra expenses of a second home, including maintenance, utilities, insurance, and property taxes. Aim for a minimum down payment of 10% for a second home mortgage.
  2. Research Lenders: Seek out reputable lenders known for offering competitive rates on second home mortgages. Carefully compare their terms and conditions.
  3. Get Pre-Qualified: Pre-qualification provides an estimate of the loan amount you might be eligible for, based on your financial details.
  4. Gather Documentation: Prepare all the required documentation, such as proof of income, credit reports, ID, and any details pertaining to the property.
  5. Complete the Application: Accurately fill in the mortgage application form provided by the lender, as the information you provide is crucial for your loan terms.
  6. Appraisal: Your lender will usually request an appraisal to verify that the value of the second home matches the loan amount.
  7. Underwriting: This phase involves a detailed examination of your financial background, the property's value, and other pertinent factors to determine your loan eligibility.
  8. Closing: Upon loan approval, you will make the down payment and execute the final mortgage documents. It's vital to thoroughly understand all the terms and conditions before finalizing.

This structured approach helps navigate the complexities of buying a second home, ensuring you're well-prepared at every step.

Plan and Save for Your Second Home with Kubera

Financial advisors often suggest that a healthy portion of your net worth, typically between 25% and 40%, should be invested in real estate to maintain a balanced portfolio. Yet, the reality for many Americans is a much higher concentration, with about 70% of their net worth wrapped up in real estate assets. The ideal balance for you will hinge on your personal financial goals and your appetite for risk, making it critical to have a clear understanding of your entire financial landscape.

To navigate the complexities of real estate investment and ensure your decisions are grounded in a comprehensive understanding of your financial health, it's crucial to have a detailed overview of your net worth and the performance of your assets over time.

Kubera streamlines this process by offering a robust platform for tracking your assets and overall net worth. By connecting to your bank accounts, investment portfolios, and even incorporating manual entries for assets like real estate or collectibles, Kubera provides a holistic view of your financial situation.

Kubera - Portfolio Tracker

The platform's dynamic dashboard showcases your portfolio value, asset allocation, and performance, alongside liabilities such as mortgages and loans, offering a clear picture of your net worth. With features like the Fast Forward function, Kubera not only aids in planning for a mortgage application but also enhances your ability to forecast and prepare for future financial scenarios. This comprehensive approach facilitates informed decision-making, enabling you to set and achieve your real estate investment goals with confidence.

Sign up for a trial of Kubera today to discover how it can assist you in planning and saving for your second home, ensuring you make the most of your assets and navigate your financial future with precision.

Sign Up to Kubera5 Star ReviewsLearn more about Kubera